My cousin says the insurer can call my treatment unnecessary and skip the bill
“got hit by two cars in one crash in Rockville and now insurance says the treatment was not medically necessary can they do that”
— Luis M., Rockville
A freelance contractor in Rockville gets caught in a two-impact crash and the insurer tries the oldest move in the book: say the care wasn't necessary.
If you were hit by two vehicles in the same crash in Rockville, the insurance company does not get to wave its hand and decide your treatment "wasn't medically necessary" just because the bills got big.
That phrase is a denial tool.
And in a two-impact wreck, it shows up fast because the carriers start playing dumb about which hit caused what.
Two impacts means two blame fights
Picture the kind of mess that happens on Veirs Mill Road, Rockville Pike, or at an ugly merge near I-270 feeding toward the Beltway. One driver hits you. A second vehicle slams into the scene seconds later. Now your body has one injury pattern, one ambulance ride, one set of scans, but multiple insurers looking for a way out.
If you're a freelance contractor with no employer benefits, this gets brutal fast. No workers' comp cushion. No paid leave. No employer health plan stepping in while the auto carriers sort out their nonsense.
The insurers know that.
So they split the crash into little pieces and argue over all of it.
One company says the first impact was minor. Another says the second impact did the real damage. Then one of them says the follow-up MRI, pain management, PT, injections, or surgery consult "wasn't medically necessary."
That doesn't mean they're right. It means they're trying to cut the file down.
"Not medically necessary" usually means "too expensive for their taste"
Here's what most people don't realize: insurance adjusters are not making a neutral medical judgment. They're usually leaning on a paper review, a coding issue, gaps in treatment, or a hired doctor who never had to drag himself out of bed with your back, neck, shoulder, or knee.
In a two-vehicle crash, they also love this line: your later treatment must be from a preexisting condition, not the collision.
That gets even uglier if you had roadside work, landscaping, hauling, ladder use, or years of physical labor already on your body. They act like a worn-down back means a crash couldn't make it worse. That's nonsense. Maryland law doesn't give a driver a discount because you were already vulnerable.
The fact pattern matters more than the insurer wants you to think
If the treatment followed the crash in a normal sequence, that matters.
ER visit in Montgomery County. Imaging. Follow-up with an orthopedist. Physical therapy. Maybe worsening symptoms later. Maybe a specialist referral after conservative care failed. That is not weird. That is how injury treatment often works.
And if the wreck was severe enough that transfer to a trauma center like R Adams Cowley Shock Trauma in Baltimore was even on the table, the "not necessary" argument starts looking especially thin.
The same goes if there was some equipment failure that made the injury worse. A defective seat belt that failed to restrain you. An airbag that didn't deploy. A seatback collapse. A faulty headrest. A defective mower attachment, trailer hitch, or roadside equipment that pushed you farther into traffic or left you exposed after the first hit.
That opens a different lane of responsibility.
It may not just be the drivers
Maryland product cases can involve strict liability, which matters because you may not need to prove the manufacturer was careless in the everyday sense. The real question is whether the part or product was defective and whether that defect caused or worsened the injury.
In this kind of Rockville crash, possible targets can include:
- the manufacturer of the defective car part or recalled product
- the seller or distributor that put it into the stream of commerce
- the installer or repair shop if bad installation caused the failure
- one or both drivers whose impacts caused the original injuries
That matters because one insurer saying your treatment was unnecessary may be covering for a bigger exposure problem. If a bad part turned a survivable hit into spinal injuries, facial fractures, or a blown knee, the medical bills stop looking "optional" in a hurry.
Maryland's rules cut both ways
Maryland is rough on contributory negligence, and insurers in this state use it like a hammer. If they can paint you as partly at fault, especially in a roadside work setup with bad signage or a sketchy work zone, they'll try.
But Maryland also does not cap auto accident damages in most ordinary personal injury and negligence cases. So when the injuries are real and the treatment tracks the trauma, the stakes are high. That's one reason the carrier fights so hard over medical necessity in the first place.
On dangerous corridors like I-95 and I-495, massive crashes with chain reactions are common. In Montgomery County, the same logic shows up on a smaller scale in multi-vehicle wrecks around Rockville. More than one impact means more than one finger-pointing insurer.
The records that usually decide this
The adjuster doesn't give a damn about your pain story unless the records lock it down.
What tends to matter most is timing, consistency, and mechanism of injury. EMS notes. ER complaints. Imaging reports. Orthopedic findings. PT records that show objective limits. Any documented worsening after the second impact. Photos of vehicle damage. Evidence of a recalled or failed part. Repair invoices. Installation records.
If a carrier says treatment wasn't medically necessary, force the issue back onto the facts: what symptoms showed up, when they showed up, what findings backed them up, and whether a defective product made the injuries worse.
That's the fight in Rockville when two cars hit in one crash and the insurer decides your recovery is somehow "extra."
This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Every case is different. If you or a loved one was injured, talk to an attorney about your situation.
Talk to a lawyer for free →